Other Spreads

Grandma's smooth Pumpkin Butter will lend the sweet and spicy taste of fresh pumpkin to any muffin, bagel or piece of toast! Ingredients Pumpkin, Sugar, Apple Cider Concentrate, Vinegar, Cinnamon, Salt, And Citric Acid.

Bold apple flavor blends perfectly with warm spices and just the right amount of sweetness, resulting in rich color and fabulous texture and flavor. Great for spreading on breads, rolls, muffins, toast, pancakes, adding to cottage cheese or as a...

Yoder's Homemade Apple Butter (No Sugar Added) is made from the same traditional recipe since day one. Every batch of apple butter is made from fresh, whole apples and is slow cooked in kettles to bring out the natural flavors in the apples and spices...

Yoder's Homemade Apple Butter has been made from the same traditional recipe since day one. This butter is made from fresh whole apples slow cooked in kettles to bring out the natural flavors in the apples and spices. This original recipe for apple...

Yoder's Homemade Apple Butter has been made from the same traditional recipe since day one. This butter is made from fresh whole apples slow cooked in kettles to bring out the natural flavors in the apples and spices. This original recipe for apple...

Our Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread is made with roasted peanuts, marshmallow and cream, for a light and creamy texture and a satisfyingly sweet taste. Mrs. Miller’s homemade peanut butter, commonly known as Amish peanut butter in...

This Marshmallow Creme is most commonly combined with peanut butter and graham crackers to make a delicious snack, but can also be spread on breads or used in fruit dips and puddings. Kids and adults will love the taste of light and fluffy Marshmallow...

Yoder’s Homemade Apple Butter has been made from the same traditional, Amish style recipe since day one. We slow-cook fresh whole apples, cinnamon, and spices in kettles to pull the best natural flavors from our ingredients with no added sugar...

Yoder’s Homemade Apple Butter has been made from the same traditional, Amish style recipe since day one. We slow-cook fresh whole apples, cinnamon, sugar, and spices in kettles to pull the best natural flavors from our ingredients. This apple...

You can’t go wrong when you have this old favorite on the table. Ingredients Apples, cane sugar, brown sugar, cinnamon, all spice.

Our Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread is made with roasted peanuts, marshmallow and cream, for a light and creamy texture and a satisfyingly sweet taste. Mrs. Miller’s homemade peanut butter, commonly known as Amish peanut butter in...