Nut Butter & Spreads

Products List

Filters

Sort By:

Display Type:
  • Mrs. Miller's 17 oz. Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread

    Mrs. Miller's 17 oz. Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread

    571325
    $7.40

    (4)

    Our Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread is made with roasted peanuts, marshmallow and cream, for a light and creamy texture and a satisfyingly sweet taste. Mrs. Miller’s homemade peanut butter, commonly known as Amish peanut butter in...
    Add to Cart
  • Cream Nut 17 oz. Natural Smooth Peanut Butter Cream Nut 17 oz. Natural Smooth Peanut Butter

    Cream Nut 17 oz. Natural Smooth Peanut Butter

    950929
    $6.50/ea
    $ 0.38/oz. | 17oz.
    Cream-Nut is simply the best tasting, all-natural peanut butter available! Koeze has been handcrafting Cream-Nut for over 90 years. Using only fresh Virginia peanuts and sea salt, you can taste the tradition of our remarkable heritage in every jar...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 16 oz. Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    Amish Wedding® 16 oz. Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    318294
    $4.80/ea
    $ 0.30/oz. | 16oz.

    (1)

    Sure, there's apples…but its the apple cider and cinnamon that will have you longing for fall all year round. Re-capture the way-it-used-to-be taste and texture. Ingredients:  Apples, cider, sugar, cinnamon, and citric acid.
    Add to Cart
  • Mrs. Miller's 12 oz. Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread Mrs. Miller's 12 oz. Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread

    Mrs. Miller's 12 oz. Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread

    571313
    $6.30

    (2)

    Our Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread is made with roasted peanuts, marshmallow and cream, for a light and creamy texture and a satisfyingly sweet taste. Mrs. Miller’s homemade peanut butter, commonly known as Amish peanut butter in...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 16 oz. Sweet Potato Butter

    Amish Wedding® 16 oz. Sweet Potato Butter

    540251
    $5.59/ea
    $ 0.35/oz. | 16oz.
    For prize-winning flavor, serve the perfect spread in Amish Wedding Foods’ Sweet Potato Butter (18oz). From time-honored Amish recipes to the true care dedicated to every small batch, Amish Wedding Foods are not just for special occasions, but to...
    Add to Cart
  • Cream Nut 17 oz. Crunchy Peanut Butter Cream Nut 17 oz. Crunchy Peanut Butter

    Cream Nut 17 oz. Crunchy Peanut Butter

    950922
    $6.50/ea
    $ 0.38/oz. | 17oz.
    If you love Cream-Nut smooth, we invite you to try our crunchy version. The same great peanut butter taste, but with extra large, flavorful, Virginia peanut chunks added, to lend an amazing crunchy texture. Ingredients:  Peanuts &...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 16 oz. Pumpkin Butter

    Amish Wedding® 16 oz. Pumpkin Butter

    540257
    $5.29/ea
    $ 0.33/oz. | 16oz.
    For prize-winning flavor, serve the perfect spread in Amish Wedding Foods’ Pumpkin Butter (16 oz.). From time-honored Amish recipes to the true care dedicated to every small batch, Amish Wedding Foods are not just for special occasions, but to...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 32 oz. Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    Amish Wedding® 32 oz. Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    318291
    $8.50/ea
    $ 0.39/oz. | 22oz.

    (2)

    Sure, there's apples…but its the apple cider and cinnamon that will have you longing for fall all year round. Re-capture the way-it-used-to-be taste and texture. Ingredients:  Apples, cider, sugar, cinnamon, and citric acid.
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 16 oz. Pecan Pumpkin Butter

    Amish Wedding® 16 oz. Pecan Pumpkin Butter

    540224
    $5.55/ea
    $ 0.35/oz. | 16oz.
    Ripe pumpkin, premium pecans and classic spices give this spread its prize-winning flavor.Pecan Pumpkin Butter (16oz)Ingredients: Pumpkin white sugar brown sugar pecans water spices vinegar salt bisulfate of soda. Ingredients:  Pumpkin, white...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 15 oz. Hot Pepper Butter

    Amish Wedding® 15 oz. Hot Pepper Butter

    540299
    $5.29/ea
    $ 0.35/oz. | 15oz.
    Be sure to try Hot Pepper Butter from Amish Wedding Foods. Hot peppers and horseradish mixes with mustard for a perfect compliment to pretzels, sandwiches, or glazes on hams. Ingredients:  hot peppers, sugar, mustard, vinegar, water, zanthum...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 8 oz. Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    Amish Wedding® 8 oz. Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    318309
    $4.29/ea
    $ 0.54/oz. | 8oz.
    Sure, there's apples…but its the apple cider and cinnamon that will have you longing for fall all year round. Re-capture the way-it-used-to-be taste and texture. Ingredients:  Apples, cider, sugar, cinnamon, and citric acid.
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Pecan Pumpkin Butter

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Pecan Pumpkin Butter

    540227
    $4.55/ea
    $ 0.51/oz. | 9oz.
    Ripe pumpkin, premium pecans and classic spices give this spread its prize-winning flavor.Pecan Pumpkin Butter (16oz)Ingredients: Pumpkin white sugar brown sugar pecans water spices vinegar salt bisulfate of soda. Ingredients:  Pumpkin,...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 16 oz. No Sugar Added Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    Amish Wedding® 16 oz. No Sugar Added Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    318300
    $8.50/ea
    $ 0.53/oz. | 16oz.

    (1)

    For prize-winning flavor, serve the perfect spread in Amish Wedding Foods’ Apple Butter (Sugar Free – No Granulated Sugar Added) (8 oz.). From time-honored Amish recipes to the true care dedicated to every small batch, Amish Wedding Foods...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Premium Peach Butter

    Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Premium Peach Butter

    540236
    $7.55/ea
    $ 0.42/oz. | 18oz.

    (2)

      Ingredients:   
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Peanut Butter Spread

    Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Peanut Butter Spread

    540248
    $8.37/ea
    $ 0.46/oz. | 18oz.
    Nice and sweet! Sometimes known as ˜church spread™ among Amish communities. Great on bread, toast, bananas, ice cream and much more….even use it as a dip for sliced apples and pretzel rods.  Ingredients:  Peanut Butter...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 8 oz. No Sugar Added Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    Amish Wedding® 8 oz. No Sugar Added Old Fashioned Apple Butter

    318315
    $4.25/ea
    $ 0.53/oz. | 8oz.
    For prize-winning flavor, serve the perfect spread in Amish Wedding Foods’ Apple Butter (Sugar Free – No Granulated Sugar Added) (8 oz.). From time-honored Amish recipes to the true care dedicated to every small batch, Amish Wedding Foods...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Peanut Butter Spread

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Peanut Butter Spread

    540275
    $5.30/ea
    $ 0.59/oz. | 9oz.
    Nice and sweet! Sometimes known as ˜church spread™ among Amish communities. Great on bread, toast, bananas, ice cream and much more….even use it as a dip for sliced apples and pretzel rods.  Ingredients:  Peanut Butter...
    Add to Cart
  • Divina 9 oz. Fig Spread Divina 9 oz. Fig Spread

    Divina 9 oz. Fig Spread

    311544
    $5.49
    Fig is our jam! We simply cannot resist this classic Mediterranean spread paired with our favorite cheese or baked atop Brie. Rich, full notes of caramel, honey and molasses are the perfect balance to savory meats, baked goods, veggies and more...
    Choose Options
  • Divina 8.5 oz. Kalamata Olive Spread Divina 8.5 oz. Kalamata Olive Spread

    Divina 8.5 oz. Kalamata Olive Spread

    311601
    $7.89
    This mouthwatering tapenade from Greece is prepared traditionally with Kalamata olives, garlic, capers and spices. A favorite of chefs looking to add bright and briny flavor without having to add extra salt. Ingredients:  Kalamata olives, red...
    Choose Options
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Premium Peach Butter

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Premium Peach Butter

    540254
    $5.30/ea
    $ 0.59/oz. | 9oz.
      Ingredients:   
    Add to Cart

Your Recently Viewed